Student News Impacting the Caribbean One Story at a Time

What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July? A Contemporary Analysis

REPRINTED from 2020 -by Jada Roberts, Dahlia Ferrol, and Sabina Ferrol

“Fellow-citizens, above your national, tumultuous joy, I hear the mournful wail of millions! whose chains, heavy and grievous yesterday, are, to-day, rendered more intolerable by the jubilee shouts that reach them.”

Words from Frederick Douglass’ speech are applicable to people of color in the U.S. in 2020 because although slavery officially “ended” in 1865, people of color still experience the effects of slavery today.

On July 4th, 1776, as America celebrated their Independence Day with the adoption of the Declaration of Independence, which claims that all men are created equal with inviolable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, Negros were unable to participate in this celebration with the rest of the nation being that they have never been treated as equals. These proclaimed rights did not adhere to Negros because of the fact that slavery was still present and existed in the first place. Fredrick Douglass, one of the most popular abolitionists and social reformers at this time, spoke out against this matter in his famous speech, “What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?”

These words from Mr. Douglass’ speech, “ The rich inheritance of justice, liberty prosperity and independence, bequeathed by your fathers, is shared by you, not by me. The sunlight that brought light and healing to you, has brought stripes and death to me”. These statements resonate with me, even in modern times, being that what is beneficial to the white man is not beneficial to the Negro. For example, police officers are paid to protect and serve all people, however, to the Negro they inflict death and pain.

Let’s expose the reality of living in America, the proclaimed “ land of the free and the home of the brave”, shall we? One idolized holiday celebrated to the masses where colorful fireworks burst high in the sky, families gather rejoicing one of the greatest ‘uplifting’ days in U.S. history is The Fourth of July. A national holiday known as one of the biggest celebrated remembrances in America centered around the commemoration of the Declaration of Independence. A written document named after highlighting the independence for all men. However not all men were considered treated fairly as their fellow neighbors.

This exposes flaws within the backbone structure of America. First, the authors of this document were the well-known Thomas Jefferson, Benjamin Franklin, John Adams, Roger Sherman, and Robert Livingston. Clearly, the primary denominator is that all were powerful white men. A document featuring the famous lines: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal” and have “certain unalienable rights” – among them “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.”

This declaration was constructed on empty promises and sweet nothings purposely written to fill a void. People of color were still feared, murdered, segregated, harassed, abused, and experienced traumatizing life experiences. The Declaration of Independence was written in June 1776, however slavery wasn’t abolished until 1865. Most notably, it was the Thirteenth Amendment (1865) which attentively ended slavery physically but emotionally. The shackles of injustice lived on within the mindset of African slaves and passed from generations to generations. People of color weren’t considered “free” in the past nor are they today. The heavy chains are un-cuffed from our wrists nevertheless it still suffocates people of colors’ existence.

On July 5, 1852, Frederick Douglass addressed the unspoken truth of American naive blindness to believe that there were equal society values, such as liberty, citizenship, and freedom. This public announcement revealed offensive disregard toward the enslaved population of the United States due to lack of freedom, liberty, and citizenship. Unfortunately, despite this declaration being hundreds of years old the same injustice is present in the 21st century. Insanity is repeating the same thing and expecting a different outcome. Injustice caused by the white population to the colored population is an ongoing repetitive act. You find that it’s different people, different acts of violences, however all are rooted from the same belief.

Fellow-citizens, above your national, tumultuous joy, I hear the mournful wail of millions! Whose chains, heavy and grievous yesterday, are, to-day, rendered more intolerable by the jubilee shouts that reach them…” – “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?“ selection -Frederick Douglass

In his “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?”, Frederick Douglass stated, “Fellow-citizens, above your national, tumultuous joy, I hear the mournful wail of millions! whose chains, heavy and grievous yesterday, are, to-day, rendered more intolerable by the jubilee shouts that reach them. If I do forget, if I do not faithfully remember those bleeding children of sorrow this day, “may my right hand forget her cunning, and may my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth!” To forget them, to pass lightly over their wrongs, and to chime in with the popular theme, would be treason most scandalous and shocking, and would make me a reproach before God and the world.

Here, this section designated to correlate Douglass’s speech into current day terms to show the shocking resemblance between the past and the future. Many families commemorate annually the Fourth of July while others have to acknowledge their loved absence due to police brutality. Families and friends may host a barbecue or boat ride on the open seas while others host a wake for their passed loved ones. As the burst fireworks exploded into the night sky, people of color are hosting candlelight vigils in honor of murdered victims from police brutality. Instead of families looking to the sky in admiration over the beautiful sky are weighed down by emotional stress from looking at a cemetery.

Racism runs deep. There is a fear of the dark; dark complexion. We are not all created equal. It is all a facade filled with pretty wording to hide the reality of who truly created that law.

In 1776, white men decided their beliefs were superior to all lives, and in the 21st century, police believe their intentions are justifiable. The pen and quill stroked unreliable ‘nothings’ by powerful white supremacists on the Declaration of Independence in 1776.

There were no African American representatives, no Native Americans “savages” representatives, no Chinese representatives, or no Hispanics representatives when creating an act for all equal parties. People of color are attacked for the shade of their complexion in which they would always be considered armed and dangerous.

The color black has always been considered a ‘feared’ color. Police brutality has perceived that the people of color are violent even unarmed. Police brutality varies with actions of withdrawn guns, body slamming our bodies, and firing nameless bullets at the innocent. Racism runs deep. There is a fear of the dark; dark complexion. We are not all created equal. It is all a facade filled with pretty wording to hide the reality of who truly created that law. This persona allows people of color to actively voice their Fourteenth Amendment which grants the rights of American citizenship. It expresses people of color in countless protests, marches, and non-violence demonstrations demanding true equality.

The words from his speech resonate with a vast majority of racial issues that have been occurring today. Now more than ever it is important to bring awareness to these matters and let America know that


Across the United States and globally, protestors have been wearing black to show unity and shouting “Black Lives Matter!” BLM is an international human rights movement that campaigns against violence and systemic racism towards black people.

Many Americans are united together to commemorate the lives taken with the Black Lives Matter movement’s progress by publicizing the “Say His Name”, “Say Her Name”, and “Say Their Name” campaign. The worst action committed by a person is to possess complete ignorance and negligence. Similar to, families and black activists holding the police accountable for their actions. The police feel entitled by the badge on their chest that makes them somewhat more superior to a civilian. Some forget the phrase “to serve and protect all” which refers to all citizens not the cops. It is scandalous to be threatened by someone’s color of skin than an actual weapon. Police are armed with guns instead of whips. The chants of “Black Lives Matter” echoes just like the slave carols sung during hardship times throughout the nation.

It’s the same story just different names all centered around people of color who are said to be free, however who are weighed down by the gravity of a white man’s knee. If people of color don’t take a stance and voice their concerns, you find that accountability would never be given. The police and justice system is in disarray. Abolitionism has become replaced with large protests in different countries taking a knee on U.S. soil. Justice and equality won’t apply to people of color unless every race is valued for their humanity rather than their pigment rate.

Unlike unnamed slaves, we can remember and honor the fallen who were taken too soon:

George Floyd, Breanna Taylor, Sandra Bland, Trayvon Martin, Eric Garner, Alton Sterling, Tamir Rice, Ahmaud Arbrey, Philando Castille, Matice Green, Michael Brown, Sean Bell, Freddie Gray, Antwon Rose Jr., Ezell Ford, Emmett Till, Freddie Gray, Michelle Cuusseaux, Atatiana Jefferson, Aura Rosser, Stephon Clark, Botham Jean, Janisha Fonville, Akai Gurley, Gabriella Nevarez, Tanisha Anderson...

Unlike unnamed slaves, we can remember and honor the fallen who were taken too soon: George Floyd, Breanna Taylor, Sandra Bland, Trayvon Martin, Eric Garner, Alton Sterling, Tamir Rice, Ahmaud Arbrey, Philando Castille, Matice Green, Michael Brown, Sean Bell, Freddie Gray, Antwon Rose Jr., Ezell Ford, Emmett Till, Freddie Gray, Michelle Cuusseaux, Atatiana Jefferson, Aura Rosser, Stephon Clark, Botham Jean, Janisha Fonville, Akai Gurley, Gabriella Nevarez, Tanisha Anderson…

 

 

49 responses to “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July? A Contemporary Analysis”

  1. Shandley Raphael Avatar
    Shandley Raphael

    In the famous 1852 speech, Frederick Douglass challenges the idea of freedom in America by asking, “What, to the American slave, is your Fourth of July?” I can understand this question in the sense that many in today’s time just celebrate holidays for the trend of it and not the meaning behind it. Many Americans see it as a big family reunion where they come together and barbecue, drink, and set off fireworks.

    This article highlighted super important parts of Douglass’s speech that still occur in today’s world. Freedom is not fully here for people of color, as we still face the same injustice that enslaved blacks faced decades ago. I appreciate the fact that the authors of this article compared the July 4th celebrations to the grief families experience and remember during this holiday. They also made it clear that people of color still face the effects of slavery, just in modern forms, such as police brutality and systemic racism. Towards the end of the article, it made me shiver a little as they listed the names of victims who were lost to police brutality and racism, emphasizing the importance of speaking up. This article made me realize how far we, people of color, still have to go just so that we can achieve true equality.

  2. Sidney James Avatar

    Reading this article made me think about how Independence Day is portrayed versus how it feels for many Black and Caribbean families. Like Douglass said, how can people celebrate freedom when others are still fighting to be treated equally? The students did a great job bringing those emotions and facts into a current perspective.

  3. J'john-na Charles Avatar
    J’john-na Charles

    This article really brought Frederick Douglass’s speech to life in today’s context. The line, “the sunlight that brought light and healing to you, has brought stripes and death to me,” struck me deeply once again, especially as the authors connected it to the realities of police brutality and racial injustice in modern times. It made me realize how much the message of Douglass’s 1852 speech still resonates in 2025.

    While some Americans celebrate freedom and independence on the Fourth of July, others are still mourning, mourning lives lost to systemic racism, inequality, and violence. That contrast mirrors exactly what Douglass described. His words weren’t just a reflection of his time; they’ve become a painful echo of our own.

    The article powerfully pointed out how the Declaration of Independence was written without people of color in mind. Today, we still feel the consequences of that exclusion, especially in how laws are enforced and who receives protection. When the authors described how the bright fireworks of Independence Day are mirrored by candlelight vigils for victims of police violence, I felt the weight of that symbolism. It’s a reminder that we’re still living in a divided reality, one of celebration for some and sorrow for others.

  4. J'john-na Charles Avatar
    J’john-na Charles

    This article really brought Frederick Douglass’s speech to life in today’s context. The line “the sunlight that brought light and healing to you, has brought stripes and death to me” hit me all over again when I saw how the authors compared it to police brutality and racial injustice today. It reminded me that while some people are celebrating freedom on the Fourth of July, others are still mourning just like Douglass said in 1852.

    The article did a great job showing how the Declaration of Independence was written without people of color in mind, and how that’s still felt now in things like who gets protected by the law and who doesn’t. When they said the fireworks of the Fourth are mirrored by candlelight vigils for the lives lost to police violence, that stuck with me. It’s a powerful reminder that we’re still living with the same unequal system, just with different names and different times.

  5. Keturah Avatar
    Keturah

    I agree that there is long lasting affects of the african american people where a continuous conflict can arise within us. Considering whether the african american people will partially or acceptingly participate in american things knowing the context of the history. It is true that we were oppressed because of the white mans desire to be hatefully superior. In present day, this identity dysfunction may live in some of them still. As african american people, I do not believe we should allow history to define our entire experience as an individual, walking around with the weight of oppression still. I am not saying to be ignorant of the events that have taken place, but to be careful about how it is causing us to be. The writer of this article has the tone of anger and resentment. I do not believe that is productive. I think the most progressive thing we can do is educate, forgive, build oneself up and never allow anyone but God to have power over you. I agree as a descendant of the enslaved i should not celebrate certain american events. I am thankful to Fredrik Douglas for educating us in this way, he has greatly contributed to the african american people through his words.

    1. J'john-na Charles Avatar
      J’john-na Charles

      I really appreciate your perspective, especially your emphasis on not allowing history to define our individual experiences. I agree that it’s important to educate ourselves and not carry the full weight of the past as a burden every day. At the same time, I believe that acknowledging the pain and anger some people feel is also part of the healing process. It’s not always about staying in resentment but about making sure those emotions are heard so that we don’t silence the truth.

      I love that you mentioned forgiveness and building oneself up, that’s powerful. Like you said, Douglass’s speech wasn’t just about anger, but about awakening. His words continue to push us to reflect, grow, and move forward. Thank you for sharing your thoughts so openly!

  6. Kavidnae Rossington Avatar
    Kavidnae Rossington

    After reading the article on the UVI Voice website, I found the part about the absurdity of celebrating freedom in a nation where Black and Caribbean people are still impacted by systematic racism and injustice particularly poignant. According to one former pupil, Douglass made the point that the enslaved people of his era found Independence Day festivities unpleasant since they exalted a freedom that not everyone had.I value how former COM120 students have reflected on Douglass’s impactful message and applied it to the modern world.

  7. Tyresse St Avatar
    Tyresse St

    This article was very well written and really made me stop and think about the racism and injustice that people of color still go through today. It pointed out a truth that’s hard to ignore that while Americans come together to celebrate freedom on the 4th of July, that freedom hasn’t fully reached everyone, especially people of color. It’s tough to watch these celebrations of independence when the system continues to fail so many. For Black Americans and other people of color, this holiday can feel like a reminder of the freedoms that were promised but not yet fully given.

    Even though the 4th of July is seen as a symbol of liberty, many people of color use this time to reflect and mourn the lives that have been lost often at the hands of law enforcement or through acts of violence and injustice. The laws and constitutional amendments that made Independence Day what it is were created without really considering the struggles, voices, and realities of Black Americans. And to this day, that gap is still felt.

    When I think about it, it’s painful that a day meant to honor equality and freedom doesn’t feel that way for everyone. Independence Day, for many, is less about celebration and more about remembering how far we still have to go to achieve true justice and equality for all.

  8. Tyresse StClair Avatar
    Tyresse StClair

    This article was very well written and really made me stop and think about the racism and injustice that people of color still go through today. It pointed out a truth that’s hard to ignore that while Americans come together to celebrate freedom on the 4th of July, that freedom hasn’t fully reached everyone, especially people of color. It’s tough to watch these celebrations of independence when the system continues to fail so many. For Black Americans and other people of color, this holiday can feel like a reminder of the freedoms that were promised but not yet fully given.

    Even though the 4th of July is seen as a symbol of liberty, many people of color use this time to reflect and mourn the lives that have been lost often at the hands of law enforcement or through acts of violence and injustice. The laws and constitutional amendments that made Independence Day what it is were created without really considering the struggles, voices, and realities of Black Americans. And to this day, that gap is still felt.

    When I think about it, it’s painful that a day meant to honor equality and freedom doesn’t feel that way for everyone. Independence Day, for many, is less about celebration and more about remembering how far we still have to go to achieve true justice and equality for all.

  9. Gianna Mathurin Avatar
    Gianna Mathurin

    One section of Douglass’ speech that still feels painfully relevant in 2025 is when he says, “This Fourth of July is yours, not mine. You may rejoice, I must mourn.” If we substitute “Caribbean” for “slave,” it sheds light on how some communities still feel excluded from full participation in the freedoms and promises the holiday represents. For many Caribbean or Black people today, systemic racism, inequality in healthcare, education, and justice continue to create a disconnect between American ideals and their lived experiences.

    If I were to rewrite this for today, I might say: “This celebration is for some, not all. While others cheer for freedom, I am reminded of the battles we still face.” This modern take reflects the frustration many feel when social progress is celebrated publicly, but the reality of injustice continues quietly. In our current climate—where protests, policy debates, and calls for equity are still urgent—Douglass’ message reminds us that until freedom is equal, celebrations will always be bittersweet for some.

  10. Sidney James Avatar
    Sidney James

    One section of the article that still feels powerfully relevant in 2025 is Douglass’s description of Independence Day celebrations as “a sham” and “a mockery” to those still oppressed. If we replace the word “slave” or “Negro” with Black or Caribbean, his argument remains painfully true: while many Americans rejoice in fireworks and patriotic speeches, Black and Caribbean communities continue to face systemic injustices such as police violence, underfunded schools, environmental racism, and income inequality. Today, it can feel hypocritical to celebrate liberty while ignoring these realities. If I were to re-write this concern to reflect our current social climate, I would emphasize how public celebrations often overshadow urgent needs in marginalized communities. For example, millions of dollars are spent on Fourth of July festivities while Black and Caribbean neighborhoods struggle with housing insecurity and lack of access to mental health resources. In 2025, true freedom demands that we pair national pride with meaningful reforms that address these inequalities and include all Americans in the promise of justice and opportunity.

  11. Sidney James Avatar
    Sidney James

    One section of the article that still feels powerfully relevant in 2025 is Douglass’s description of Independence Day celebrations as “a sham” and “a mockery” to those still oppressed. If we replace the word “slave” or “Negro” with Black or Caribbean, his argument remains painfully true: while many Americans rejoice in fireworks and patriotic speeches, Black and Caribbean communities continue to face systemic injustices such as police violence, underfunded schools, environmental racism, and income inequality. Today, it can feel hypocritical to celebrate liberty while ignoring these realities. If I were to re-write this concern to reflect our current social climate, I would emphasize how public celebrations often overshadow urgent needs in marginalized communities. For example, millions of dollars are spent on Fourth of July festivities while Black and Caribbean neighborhoods struggle with housing insecurity and lack of access to mental health resources. In 2025, true freedom demands that we pair national pride with meaningful reforms that address these inequalities and include all Americans in the promise of justice and opportunity.

  12. Keijhenae Petersen Avatar
    Keijhenae Petersen

    The article highlights the fact that we’re facing the same challenges Douglas described in his speech. Throughout U.S. history, the presidency has been dominated by white, middle-aged men with the exception of one Black president who served two terms from 2009 to 2017. There has never been a Native American, Asian, or Latino president since the founding of the U.S. government. This shows that the roots of inequality and racism are still deeply embedded in American politics. The U.S. is often described as a melting pot of people from diverse backgrounds, so we must ask: why have nearly all our leaders looked the same? A nation built on the backs of multiple races and stolen from its Indigenous inhabitants has no right to be governed by policies that discriminate against people simply trying to live in the so-called “land of the free.”

  13. Keijhenae Petersen Avatar
    Keijhenae Petersen

    The article highlights the fact we’re battling the same challenges that were described in Douglas’ speech in present day. Throughout U.S. history, the presidency has been dominated by white, middle-aged men with the exception of one Black president who served two terms from 2009 to 2017. There has never been a Native American, Asian, or Latino president since the founding of the U.S. government. This shows that the roots of inequality and racism are still deeply embedded in American politics. The U.S. is often described as a melting pot of people from diverse backgrounds, so we must ask: why have nearly all our leaders looked the same? A nation built on the backs of multiple races and stolen from its Indigenous inhabitants has no right to be governed by policies that discriminate against people simply trying to live in the so-called “land of the free.”

  14. Keijhenae Petersen Avatar
    Keijhenae Petersen

    The section I chose to focus on is the part discussing the issue of a group of white men deciding that their values are above all others:
    “ In 1776, white men decided their beliefs were superior to all lives, and in the 21st century, police believe their intentions are justifiable. The pen and quill stroked unreliable ‘nothings’ by powerful white supremacists on the Declaration of Independence in 1776.”

    This statement still holds true in 2025. Throughout U.S. history, the presidency has been dominated by white, middle-aged men with the exception of one Black president who served two terms from 2009 to 2017. There has never been a Native American, Asian, or Latino president since the founding of the U.S. government. This shows that the roots of inequality and racism are still deeply embedded in American politics. The U.S. is often described as a melting pot of people from diverse backgrounds, so we must ask: why have nearly all our leaders looked the same? A nation built on the backs of multiple races and stolen from its Indigenous inhabitants has no right to be governed by policies that discriminate against people simply trying to live in the so-called “land of the free.”

    Rewrite:
    In 1776, the “founding fathers” wrote words of freedom that excluded everyone but themselves. Today, we still see that legacy alive where power is kept for the elite, and justice is selective. In 2025, racism remains deeply woven into the fabric of American life: from racially motivated voter suppression to the inhumane treatment of migrants in ICE detention centers. Police violence is still justified as “keeping order,” even when it disproportionately targets Black and Brown people. Meanwhile, the political system continues to elevate the same white, male image of leadership, ignoring the voices and struggles of people of color. In 2024 we came close to having our first black and Asian female president of Jamaican background however the threads of racism made citizens deem her unworthy of serving our country. The promises written in the Declaration of Independence still remain unkept for those whose lives are policed and rejected. Until equality is truly practiced America’s founding words will remain as lies.

  15. Josendy Morel Avatar
    Josendy Morel

    The article talks about how some families celebrate the Fourth of July as a fun holiday, but for many Black and Caribbean people, it’s a reminder of everything their ancestors went through and the unfair treatment that still exists today. Frederick Douglass gave a powerful speech about this, pointing out that even though it was 1852, Black people were still being treated like they were enslaved. He connected the past to the present by calling them the descendants of enslaved people and questioning what freedom really meant for them. Even though slavery is over, we still deal with racism and inequality in different ways. Back then it was slavery, now it’s things like police brutality, unfair treatment in the justice system, and how Black and Caribbean people are often seen as less. Today’s generation is more aware and is using their voices, social media, and protests to call out these issues.

  16. Yvonisha Lawrence Avatar
    Yvonisha Lawrence

    This article does a great job of highlighting how the Fourth of July holiday came about. Frederick Douglass talks about the struggles and hardships that minorities had, and the author of this article does a great job of showcasing the fact that these inequalities still happen in modern-day society. Specifically, it shows the difference between how police approach black people versus white people. Most importantly, it talks about the constitution and who it was made for.

  17. Levorn Monchery Avatar
    Levorn Monchery

    This sentiment remains deeply relevant. In Puerto Rico, the US, and around the Caribbean, ongoing disproportionate use of force against Black and Caribbean people some even killed by police during protests or everyday stops echoes those “chains of injustice.” Recent high-profile cases, community mistrust, and calls for independent oversight show this is far from resolved. Douglass criticized America’s “hollow mockery” of freedom. Today, the enduring fear that Black and Caribbean people feel during a routine interaction with authority when others are celebrating independence shows the same hypocrisy persists. Holidays meant to represent liberation still expose deep racial wounds.

  18. LeAna Noel Avatar

    In my honest view, “What A Slave is The Fourth Of July” clarified how you, not me, share the magnificent legacy of justice, liberty, wealth, and independence that your fathers left you. I have stripes and death because of the sunlight that gave you brightness and healing. Furthermore, this demonstrated the hypocrisy of commemorating independence while denying enslaved people the same rights, which is still pertinent in 2025. Because it so well captures the harsh social and political reality of the day, it represents our current social context.

  19. Le’Ana Noel Avatar

    @ Standard) Fluency Humanize
    Formal
    Acad
    I think that was made clear in “What to a Slave Is the Fourth of July?” The sun that provided you with light and healing is the reason I am dead and have stripes.
    Additionally, it showed how hypocritical it is to celebrate independence while denying enslaved people the same rights, a that will still be relevant in 2025.

  20. LeAna Noel Avatar

    Additionally, this brought to light the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying enslaved people the same rights, which is still pertinent in 2025. Because it so well captures the harsh social and political reality of the day, it represents our current social context. Lastly blacks were the highlighted the most during fourth of July independence which was to share freedom with one another .

  21. Le’Ana Noel Avatar

    “What A Slave is The Fourth Of July” made that clear, in my honest opinion. Because of the sunlight that provided you with light and healing, I have stripes and am dead. Additionally, this illustrated the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying the same rights to enslaved people, a
    that relevant in 2025

  22. LeAna Noel Avatar

    “What A Slave is The Fourth Of July” explained how The rich inheritance of justice, liberty prosperity and independence, bequeathed by your fathers, is shared by you, not by me. . Furthermore this highlighted the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying those same rights to enslaved people which is relevant in 2025. It reelects our current social climate because it powerfully reflects the stark social and political realities of the time.

  23. LeAna Noel Avatar

    “What A Slave is The Fourth Of July” explained how The rich inheritance of justice, liberty prosperity and independence, bequeathed by your fathers, is shared by you, not by me. The sunlight that brought light and healing to you, has brought stripes and death to me”. Furthermore this highlighted the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying those same rights to enslaved people which is relevant in 2025. It reelects our current social climate because it powerfully reflects the stark social and political realities of the time.

  24. LeAna Noel Avatar

    To my honest opinion “What A Slave is The Fourth Of July” explained how The rich inheritance of justice, liberty prosperity and independence, bequeathed by your fathers, is shared by you, not by me. The sunlight that brought light and healing to you, has brought stripes and death to me”. Furthemore this highlighted the hypocrisy of celebrating independence while denying those same rights to enslaved people which is relevant in 2025. It reelects our current social climate because it powerfully reflects the stark social and political realities of the time.

  25. Kemari Hay Avatar
    Kemari Hay

    The article does a great job of showing how the past isn’t just history; it’s still alive in what we go through now. It’s honestly upsetting how little has changed in some ways. Celebrating freedom while people are still being killed for the color of their skin? That’s not real freedom. I feel like this article called out the hypocrisy and forced me to think about what this holiday really means—not just for me, but for the people who’ve never truly been free in this country.

  26. LeAna Noel Avatar

    To my honest opinion “What A Slave is The Fourth Of July expained how negros experienced prejustice issues and equality issues as stated “Negros were unable to participate in this celebration with the rest of the nation being that they have never been treated as equals. These proclaimed rights did not adhere to Negros because of the fact that slavery was still present and existed in the first place. Furthermore The lived realities of people who endure systematic injustice and discrimination frequently conflict with the country’s independence which was mostly against negros

  27. Aaron Morales Avatar
    Aaron Morales

    This article made me stop and think. It shows how the Fourth of July does not mean the same thing for everyone, especially for people like us in Black and Caribbean communities. While many people are out celebrating freedom, others continue to deal with the pain, history, and injustice that persist today. The way the article connected Frederick Douglass’ words to current issues, such as police brutality and unequal treatment, really stood out to me. It was a potent reminder that just because laws have changed, it does not mean things are truly equal. The fight for absolute freedom and justice remains alive.

  28. LeAna Noel Avatar
    LeAna Noel

    To my honest opinion the article ” What to the slave is the fourth discussed how colored people were treated unfairly and The immorality of commemorating American independence when millions of slaves were held in bondage were criticized. Furthermore based on my understanding of the article black wasn’t recognized at all only whites were recognized for their patriotism . In Addition to black slaves being judged by whites are still happening in 2025. The prejustice that I explained give a synopis on how the nations independence had clashes alongside people who endure systematic injustice and discrimination in their daily lives especially colored people.

  29. Anaizjah Dennis Avatar
    Anaizjah Dennis

    The Fourth of July came out to me differently after reading this article. The manner in which it linked the words of Frederick Douglass to the fact that Black and Caribbean people continue to associate with today was very real to me. The most striking part was that of comparing fireworks gone off by families to other people lighting candles in memory of their beloved people killed by the police. It made me think, as it demonstrates that things are unfair to this day. Though slavery is no more, the stigma and apprehension of being born with dark skin is very much evident. This article is very informative, it has enabled me to understand that we are still struggling to attain freedom and equality, which was envisioned many years ago.

  30. Jeisly Petersen Avatar
    Jeisly Petersen

    This article does a great job connecting Frederick Douglass’s powerful speech to today’s world. I like how the students broke down each section in a way that makes it easy to understand and relate to. It really shows that even though the speech was written in 1852, many of the issues Frederick Douglass talked about are still affecting Black and Caribbean people in 2025. It makes you think about how much more work needs to be done.

  31. Jeisly Petersen Avatar
    Jeisly Petersen

    This article does a great job connecting Frederick Douglass’s powerful speech to today’s world. I like how the students broke down each section in a way that makes it easy to understand and relate to. It really shows that even though the speech was written in 1852, many of the issues Frederick Douglas talked about are still affecting Black and Caribbean people in 2025. It makes you think about how much more work needs to be done.

  32. Uchenna Ferris Avatar
    Uchenna Ferris

    This article highlights how Frederick Douglass’s words still echo in today’s world. It does a great job connecting the historic realities of slavery and racism to the current experiences of Black and Caribbean communities. The part that stood out most to me was how they pointed out the painful contradiction of celebrating freedom on the Fourth of July while so many still face injustice, discrimination, and loss due to police brutality and systemic racism. It’s a powerful reminder that for some, Independence Day feels more like a reminder of inequality than a celebration of freedom. The article encourages all of us to reflect on the true meaning of freedom, not just for some, but for everyone.

  33. Uchenna Ferris Avatar
    Uchenna Ferris

    This article highlights how Frederick Douglass’s words still echo in today’s world. It does a great job connecting the historic realities of slavery and racism to the current experiences of Black and Caribbean communities. The part that stood out most to me was how they pointed out the painful contradiction of celebrating freedom on the Fourth of July while so many still face injustice, discrimination, and loss due to police brutality and systemic racism. It’s a powerful reminder that for some, Independence Day feels more like a reminder of inequality than a celebration of freedom. The article encourages all of us to reflect on the true meaning of freedom, not just for some, but for everyone.

  34. Brianna George Avatar
    Brianna George

    I completely agree with this article. Many of us tend to celebrate national holidays without knowing the true history behind these “big holidays.” It’s important to recognize and understand that not everyone has the same experiences with freedom in this country. This article really showed that we can’t turn a blind eye and celebrate while others mourn. This holiday has a deeper meaning that others feel when this time comes around. This day was created by White men for white men pretending to believe that this declaration of independence created equality, freedom, and liberty for all but it only freed the creators. In reality, they wrote what they knew colored people of America wanted to see or hear rather than belieiving it themselves.

  35. Abigail Rose Avatar
    Abigail Rose

    This article offers such a powerful and emotional reflection on a part of American history that’s too often overlooked during the July 4th celebrations. The way it ties Frederick Douglass’ speech to what’s happening today, from systemic racism to police brutality, is deeply impactful. I was especially struck by the contrast between how some celebrate with fireworks and barbecues while others mourn loved ones lost to injustice. It really forces you to rethink what freedom and independence mean and who actually gets to experience them. The writing is honest, raw, and necessary. It doesn’t just bring attention to the past, but calls out the present in a way that’s impossible to ignore

  36. Jakiesha Brandy Avatar

    I’ll focus on the section addressing police brutality and its reflection of our current social climate in 2025.

    “Police officers are paid to protect and serve all people, however, to the Negro they inflict death and pain.”

    This statement from the article, rephrased to refer to Black/Caribbean people, remains profoundly relevant in 2025. The core issue raised by Douglass, the hypocrisy of celebrating freedom while a segment of the population is denied it, finds a direct parallel in the experiences of Negro communities regarding law enforcement. While slavery as a legal institution ended, the article powerfully argues that “the shackles of injustice lived on within the mindset of African slaves and passed from generations to generations,” and that “The heavy chains are uncuffed from our wrists, nevertheless it still suffocates people of colors’ existence.” This is tragically evident in the ongoing issue of police brutality and racial bias within the criminal justice system.

    In 2025, we continue to see disproportionate encounters between Negro individuals and law enforcement, often resulting in tragic outcomes. Statistics from organizations like the NAACP and Mapping Police Violence highlight these disparities. For example, while Black people make up around 13.4% of the U.S. population, they accounted for 22% of fatal police shootings from 2013-2025. This means Black people are killed by police at over twice the rate of White Americans. Furthermore, Black people are more likely to be stopped without just cause, searched, arrested, and experience the threat or use of force during police encounters.

    The article mentions “the mournful wail of millions! whose chains, heavy and grievous yesterday, are, to-day, rendered more intolerable by the jubilee shouts that reach them.” This imagery is still applicable. While many Americans celebrate the Fourth of July with fireworks and festivities, for many Negro families, it’s a day that can highlight the pain of systemic injustice, with protests and vigils for victims of police violence serving as a stark reminder of unfulfilled promises of liberty and equality.

    Rewriting/Elaborating on this Concern for our Current Social Climate (2025):

    The proclaimed mandate for law enforcement to ‘protect and serve’ continues to ring hollow for many Negro communities in 2025. Despite decades of activism, legislative attempts, and increased public awareness spurred by movements like Black Lives Matter, the disproportionate impact of policing on our communities persists. The anguish experienced by families whose loved ones are lost to police violence, often in situations where excessive force or racial bias is evident, underscores a fundamental betrayal of the promise of equal protection under the law. The legal system, intended to deliver justice, too often perpetuates cycles of incarceration and trauma, with Negro individuals facing higher rates of arrest, harsher sentencing, and disproportionate representation in the incarcerated population. This ongoing reality demonstrates that the ‘chains’ Frederick Douglass spoke of, though metaphorical now, still bind, manifest in systemic inequities that deny true liberty and security to millions.

  37.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    The article “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July? A Contemporary Analysis” explains how Frederick Douglass’s 1852 speech still connects to the lives of Black and Caribbean people today. It shows that while many Americans celebrate freedom on the Fourth of July, people of color are still fighting for justice and equality. The authors talk about how racism, police brutality, and unfair treatment continue to affect Black communities. Reading this article made me feel sad and frustrated because it shows how little has changed for people of color over the years. It also made me more aware of the pain that can come with holidays like the Fourth of July. I believe it’s important to speak up, just like Douglass did, so that one day everyone can truly be free and equal in this country.

  38. Lizmarie Arno Avatar
    Lizmarie Arno

    The article “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July? A Contemporary Analysis” explains how Frederick Douglass’s 1852 speech still connects to the lives of Black and Caribbean people today. It shows that while many Americans celebrate freedom on the Fourth of July, people of color are still fighting for justice and equality. The authors talk about how racism, police brutality, and unfair treatment continue to affect Black communities. Reading this article made me feel sad and frustrated because it shows how little has changed for people of color over the years. It also made me more aware of the pain that can come with holidays like the Fourth of July. I believe it’s important to speak up, just like Douglass did, so that one day everyone can truly be free and equal in this country.

  39. Anna Gilbert Avatar
    Anna Gilbert

    This article was thoughtfully written and effectively highlighted the ongoing racism and injustice that people of color continue to face in the 21st century. It’s hard to comprehend how Americans celebrate the 4th of July as a symbol of independence when the system has done so little to improve the treatment of people of color in this country. While the holiday is often embraced by white Americans as a celebration of freedom, many people of color use this time to mourn the lives lost, often at the hands of white individuals and law enforcement officers who are meant to serve and protect all citizens equally. The laws and constitutional amendments that established this day as a national holiday were created without truly considering the experiences or perspectives of Black Americans.For many, Independence Day is a reminder of freedoms promised but not yet fully realized

  40. S. Petersen (COM 120 Summer II 2025) Avatar
    S. Petersen (COM 120 Summer II 2025)

    I have a complicated relationship with America and her ideals. I am patriotic, but I am constantly criticizing, questioning and demanding that America embrace all who live within her boundaries. What I unequivocally do celebrate is my right to speak the truth, to challenge the status quo and to demand change. I am simultaneously ashamed and proud, hopeful and disappointed. America is at times difficult to love. Some of us celebrate the 4th of July and some of us don’t. For me it’s just fireworks because my people weren’t included in that freedom. I don’t begrudge any black person who celebrates it I just wonder why.

  41. S. Petersen (Summer II 2025) Avatar
    S. Petersen (Summer II 2025)

    I have a complicated relationship with America and her ideals. I am patriotic, but I am constantly criticizing, questioning and demanding that America embrace all who live within her boundaries. What I unequivocally celebrate is my right to speak the truth, to challenge the status quo and to demand change. I am simultaneously ashamed and proud, hopeful and disappointed. America is at times difficult to love. Some of us celebrate the 4th of July and some of us don’t. For me it’s just fireworks because my people weren’t included in that freedom. I don’t begrudge any black person who celebrates it I just wonder why.

  42. Ammiel Casey Avatar

    To my understanding of the article, it describes how the 4th of July is viewed as a holiday to the white population as opposed to the black population. I agree with the point of the article as it states the changes of slavery is still being weighed down on the negro individuals who are receiving malicious and unequal treatment from others up to today. The Declaration of Independence was indeed written on empty promises, which did not really bring forth the effect of every individual being treated in an equal manner. One of Frederick Douglas’ statement in his quote, “Fellow-citizens, above your national, tumultuous joy, I hear the mournful wail of millions!”, cause me to perceive that he saw and understood completely the bondage the millions of African Americans were going through and the mindset of slavery as it was back then would still continue; still in different forms and disguises. The mindset and ignorance of racism have not really left the nation, because it still exists, but in different ways and forms today. The crimes a large majority of African Americans are still undergoing and dealing with today is worse this year. Let alone, the democracy of negros who have lived America for years and decades is on the line today under the US current presidential administration in 2025. That being said, the sentiment of Frederik Douglas’ quote is correct when he spoke about millions who wear the chains of slavery physically, emotionally, and spiritually; even if a large majority of African Americans are not bound by physical fetters on their wrists and ankles, the stress and the self-hatred and discrimination is still being felt among a multitude of African Americans today. Others today may view July 4th as a time of celebration for gaining independence and freedom, but not to those who had and still receive separate and unequal treatment from others.

    1. S. Petersen (COM 120 Summer II 2025) Avatar
      S. Petersen (COM 120 Summer II 2025)

      I have a complicated relationship with America and her ideals. I am patriotic, but I am constantly criticizing, questioning and demanding that America embrace all who live within her boundaries. What I unequivocally do celebrate is my right to speak the truth, to challenge the status quo and to demand change. I am simultaneously ashamed and proud, hopeful and disappointed. America is at times difficult to love. Some of us celebrate the 4th of July and some of us don’t. For me it’s just fireworks because my people weren’t included in that freedom. I don’t begrudge any black person who celebrates it I just wonder why.

  43. Jackline j. James Avatar
    Jackline j. James

    This article was well presented and a great effort was made by the writer to include the level of racism and injustice that people of color still face in the 21st century. It is difficult to understand how Americans celebrate the 4th of July as independence day when the system has done very little to change the way people of color are treated in the land. If we are in the land of the free and home of the brave this freedom is only celebrated by the whites because during this holiday season the people of color use this time to mourn the loss of their loved ones who lost their lives at the hands of the white and particularly by the police who are expected to protect and serve them and not only the whites. The whites who formulated these laws and amended the constitution to observe this day as a holiday had no inkling of how the blacks felt at that time and not much consideration or emphasis was placed on the colored when these amendments were being implemented. It is said that the people of color can’t be seen as equal and enjoy the same liberty and freedom that the whites enjoy.

  44. Sonaai Oscar Avatar
    Sonaai Oscar

    The article talks about racism. Families celebrate July 4th as a happy day, but some blacks think about their lost ones. Frederik Douglas gave a speech that addressed inequality. He connected the past and the present by referring to the blacks as descendants. He asked what is July 4th to an enslaved person by basically calling himself and the people of his present time enslaved. Slavery is over, but we still experience inequality. After all, the white man believes they are superior. In the past, the problem was slavery, but today the situation is police brutality, and this generation is coming together and holding the police accountable. A protest started after George Floyd’s death because the police killed him due to racism. People used social media to help spread the word, and everyone chanted “black lives matter which is still a common phrase used today.

  45. Kadejsha T. Avatar
    Kadejsha T.

    I agree with everything this article has to say. If the constitution was made to also support minorities none of the things that were mentioned would have occurred. The truth is that constitution was not made for minorities it was made for the comfort of the white people. The constitution was made by white men; this only contributes to that belief. If the constitution was made for all then why was everyone not included in its making? It is a very good question that has yet to be answered.

    1. Kanesha T. Avatar
      Kanesha T.

      I completely agree with your stance. The constitution was made mainly for the white men in power created under their values and circumstances. You asked the question ” If the constitution was made for all then why was everyone not included in its making?”. It made me wonder- if the constitution was made including the voices of the minorities that are actually affected by racism, what would racism look like now? Sadly, we may never know. What’s even more concerning is that in 2025, our freedom of speech feels like it’s slowly being taken away — in a nation that claims to be “the land of the free.”

  46. Janelle Casey Avatar
    Janelle Casey

    Independence day is a beloved holiday for families in America today, and has celebration been since 1776. The celebration however is controversial, because of the maltreatment and oppression of the black people. They were still slaves, and this was not independence for everyone. Frederick Douglas spoke to this, saying “ The rich inheritance of justice, liberty prosperity and independence, bequeathed by your fathers, is shared by you, not by me. The sunlight that brought light and healing to you, has brought stripes and death to me”. The truth is that the entry to the declaration of independence from Great Brittan was simply written as a pacifier for the people, a veneer of morals and righteousness. The never did intend to give us a chance at a pursuit of happiness, or treat us equally. The Dangers of racism have never left America, and the crimes against African Americans are proof that for every step forward we make, there ten steps made back. For all that has changed in our favor, twice as much has gotten worse. What I learned in school was that Police men and women were protectors of kids like me, that I could count on them to help. It’s been a long time since 2007 and a lot has happened. Two police killings in just this year, were that of Amir Locke on February 2, and Patrick Lyoya on April 4. Amir was shot during no-knock investigation, Patrick, an African refugee was chased down and shot in the back of the head. America may no longer belong to England, but people like politicians and officers constantly show us that we still belong the fear of being black in America.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *